Beyond Brushstrokes: Gallery Breakups

When Art and Business Decide to 'See Other People' - Let's Make It an Amicable Split

Written by GUNNA FREIVALDE | AMG ATTORNEYS

Photo credit: Monika M. Kubiak Photography

THE ART OF SPLITTING UP

Once as rare as a genuine smile on a critic's face, their partings are now practically commonplace. Picture this: an artist and a gallery, tangoing through the art scene in perfect harmony. But as with any dance, eventually, someone might want to try a different rhythm. Maybe the artist's artistic compass starts pointing towards bolder, uncharted territory while the gallery feels more comfortable waltzing with established styles. Or perhaps the ever-evolving market demands a salsa for innovation, and neither partner is quite ready to switch steps.

Here's where things get interesting. Some high-profile separations have gone down with all the subtlety of a dropped chandelier (think disagreements about representation strategies or artistic direction). We've all heard the whispers about those breakups, the ones that leave the art world buzzing like a hive before a queen bee selection. Dramatic exits, disagreements about artistic direction – it's enough to make your head spin faster than a centrifuge in a Pollock studio.

However, after the first splash of emotions, most separations happen with the grace of a well-executed pirouette. At the end of the day – artists and galleries might simply realize they've grown in different directions, and a clean break allows them both to pursue their artistic visions with renewed vigor.

THE UPSIDE OF UNSHACKLING

So, what does an artist do when they're single on the art scene?

The possibilities are as vast as a collector's bank account!

Online platforms offer exciting new avenues to showcase work, while self-curated exhibitions provide a platform for artistic autonomy. After all, sometimes a little self-expression is just what the doctor (or, in this case, the curator) ordered.

Joining forces with fellow creatives and sharing resources, studio space, and even exhibition opportunities. It's like having a built-in support group and brainstorming buddy, all rolled into one.

Why not immerse yourself in a new environment, focusing on the craft, and potentially connecting with a whole new audience while discovering hidden boosts of creativity. Art residencies might do just the right thing, and it could be the perfect creative vacation with the potential for some serious artistic growth.

There is always room for collaboration. Why not team up with fellow artists for a unique project. Not only can this spark new creative ideas, but it can also help you tap into each other's networks and audiences.

Remember, being single on the art scene does not mean you have to go it alone. Think of it as a chance to play the field! Unleash your inner art world social butterfly and explore the wealth of possibilities. Consider artist collectives – your own personal entourage of creative minds, ready to share studio space, brainstorm like nobody's business, and maybe even crash at your place after a particularly inspiring opening night.

So, chin up, single artist! The art world is your oyster (or perhaps a more highbrow metaphor, like a priceless Ming vase waiting to be discovered). With a dash of creativity and a sprinkle of resourcefulness, you'll be navigating the scene with confidence and keeping that artistic flame burning brighter than ever.

A FAREWELL FANDANGO, NOT A FLEETING FLING

The recent rise in artist-gallery separations might leave some wondering if it's' a mere blip on the art world's radar, a temporary artistic "redecorating". However, a closer look reveals a more compelling narrative. The rise of social media and digital marketing further fuels this tendency towards artistic independence. While galleries still offer valuable connections and exposure, some artists might find the siren song of self-promotion too enticing to resist. After all, in the ever-evolving art world, a clean break can sometimes be the prelude to a thrilling new artistic adventure.

THE "IT'S NOT YOU, IT'S ME" CLAUSE: LEGAL DO'S AND DON'TS

Let's keep it straight – don't let the legalese leave you blue! The word that strikes fear into the heart of even the most fearless art collector (and possibly sends lawyers into raptures). However, while navigating artist-gallery separations might feel like traversing a legal minefield blindfolded, a basic understanding of the legalities can prevent artistic meltdowns (and, dare I say, potentially ruinous lawsuits).

Think of a contract as the "prenup" of the art world. And here I am, allowing a bit of a luxury to repeat myself: turns out I wrote a whole story about contracts in my first piece for the magazine: Issue VI, "Shattering the Frame: Mastering the Art of Entrepreneurial Success".

Ideally, it's a document drafted by an art lawyer who is more Hemingway than legalese, clear and concise rather than labyrinthine. This all-important document should meticulously outline the terms of both "getting together" and "saying goodbye" with the precision of a Swiss watchmaker.

Who gets to keep the unsold artwork after the proverbial "breakup"? Does it stay with the gallery, gathering dust and longing for a new home, or does it boomerang back to the studio for a fresh start?

And beyond the ownership of unsold masterpieces, a thought should also be given for finer details of a potential artistic "divorce". Think marketing materials – who gets to keep using captivating images of the artwork to woo future collectors after the "breakup"?

Social media promotion might also need a clear exit strategy – can the gallery continue singing the artist's praises online, and for how long?

Exclusivity clauses deserve a good look too – did the contract lock the artist into a committed relationship with the gallery? If so, how long does that commitment last after the partnership dissolves? Future sales of the artist's work are another consideration – how will any newfound windfalls be split, and does the original commission rate still apply?

Even the logistics of returning artwork need a clear plan – who foots the bill for those potential shipping headaches?

Finally, a touch of confidentiality can go a long way. Does the contract have a clause protecting sensitive information from being spilled like coffee on your new silk blouse?

By addressing these additional details, it is possible to ensure a clean separation, allowing to move on with minimal artistic baggage and a renewed focus on creating phenomenal art.

Intellectual property – the invisible ink that binds an artist's creation to their soul (and potentially or hopefully to some lucrative licensing deals). Think of it as the artistic equivalent of a royal decree, proclaiming you, the artist, the undisputed Rembrandt of your masterpiece. Contracts with the gallery might be like those mischievous imps in fairytales, granting them permission to, say, reproduce miniature versions of your works on a seemingly endless array of merchandise – from fancy mugs emblazoned with your artwork to chic tote bags featuring a detail so small it requires a magnifying glass to appreciate (hopefully, it's a captivating detail, not a rogue paint smudge). Think of it as artistic royalties in miniature form, a steady trickle of income that lets you focus on creating more masterpieces, not perfecting your barista skills.

Now, when the artistic partnership takes a turn towards "farewell, and thanks for all the sales", these licensing agreements need a good, long look in the metaphorical magnifying glass (because, let's face it – I already got glasses that remind wine bottle bottoms while in law school to read through all these never-ending legal publications and because legalese can be smaller than the aforementioned detail on the tote bag). Are these masterpieces still a good fit for the gallery's brand, or is it time for them to find a new home (perhaps nestled on a collector's shelf, not a coffee cup)?

By reassessing these licensing arrangements during a separation, both artist and gallery can ensure their artistic offspring are represented fairly. Imagine it – your creation, once adorning a mug, now taking pride of place in a collector's living room, sparking conversations, and spreading its creative joy...and some profit, through the world.

And since not all breakups are a "clean cut", let's give a thought or two to the varied opinions and the possible solution. Contracts often come equipped with built-in dispute resolution mechanisms, acting as the peace pipes of the art world. Think mediation – a neutral third party steps in, acting as a kind of artistic referee, striving to guide both sides towards a solution that leaves everyone feeling like a winner (and getting the artwork safely out of the line of fire).

Then there's arbitration – as an arbitrator for the Court of Arbitration for Art myself, I can give you the exact description of how it looks. Imagine a judge who has a creative spirit but has never had the courage to admit that their artistic skills are worth a closer look, but who understands and has trained themselves to dive into the world of legalese. This chosen arbitrator hears both sides of the story and delivers a binding verdict, ensuring a swift (unlikely in the traditional court) and hopefully amicable resolution to the artistic disagreement.

By including these dispute resolution mechanisms in contracts, artists and galleries can avoid potentially expensive and time-consuming legal battles, allowing them to get back to what truly matters – creating phenomenal art (and hopefully avoiding any future paintbrush-related skirmishes).

BEYOND THE LEGALESE: A GUIDE TO GRACEFUL ARTISTIC GOODBYES

Contracts may be the legalese life rafts in the stormy seas of artist-gallery separations, but there's more to navigating these separations than legalese alone. Ethical considerations, the invisible threads that bind trust and professionalism, are equally important. Here's where things get interesting – think of it as the "etiquette of artistic breakups."

Communication is key! Maintaining a frank and open conversation throughout the parting process is like sunshine after a storm. It fosters trust, clears up misunderstandings (because let's face it, crossed wires can be as disastrous as spilled paint in an art studio!), and paves the way for a smooth transition.

Honesty is the best policy, even in the art world. Both artists and galleries should be upfront about their reasons for parting ways. Is the artist yearning for new artistic horizons, while the gallery craves a different stylistic direction? A clear and honest exchange allows for a respectful "farewell, and thanks for all the fish" (or, more appropriately, all the sold artwork!).

Remember, fairness is the golden rule, even in the sometimes-unpredictable world of art. Ensuring an equitable distribution of proceeds from sales and adhering to the terms of the contract is essential for upholding ethical standards. Think of it as artistic karma – treating everyone involved fairly ensures a positive reputation and keeps the doors open for future collaborations within the art community.

Professionalism is paramount, even during a "breakup." Upholding integrity throughout the process protects the reputation of both the artist and the gallery within the art world. Imagine it – a clean separation paves the way for future partnerships and ensures everyone walks away with their heads held high (and their artistic egos intact). So, the next time you're embarking on an artistic partnership, remember: a focus on ethical considerations is like the finishing touch on a masterpiece – it elevates the experience and ensures a graceful and professional artistic goodbye.

THE ART OF ARTISTIC BREAKUP

So, the decision is made, the "farewell tour" is booked (metaphorically speaking), and it's time to navigate the practicalities of an artist-gallery separation. Fear not, intrepid artists and gallerists! Think of it as the "logistics of the artistic split" – a chance to ensure a smooth transition and minimize any post-breakup headaches.

First things first – the art! Cataloging and documenting your artistic inventory is like creating a detailed map of your creative treasures. This ensures complete clarity regarding ownership and disposition of the artwork after the "parting of ways." Imagine it – a well-organized inventory prevents any artistic equivalent of a missing sock situation (because a missing masterpiece is a disaster no one wants to deal with!).

Resolving all financial obligations, including outstanding payments, commissions, and any lingering expenses, is crucial for a clean and amicable separation. Think of it as artistic closure – settling accounts ensures everyone walks away feeling financially secure and ready to embark on new artistic adventures.

Just because the partnership is dissolving doesn't mean the artistic connection has to vanish entirely! Both artists and galleries can explore alternative avenues for collaboration. Joint exhibitions, where the artist showcases their work in a different gallery space, or referral agreements, where the gallery recommends the artist to potential collectors, are just a few possibilities. After all, maintaining a positive and professional relationship within the art community can open doors to exciting artistic endeavors down the line. So, the next time you're embarking on an artistic partnership, remember: a focus on practical considerations is like the final brushstroke on a masterpiece – it ensures a smooth and successful artistic separation, paving the way for a bright and creative future.

IN CONCLUSION: A FAREWELL WALTZ, NOT A JUMBLED AUCTION HOUSE SCRAMBLE

Artist-gallery separations, while not as dramatic as a public auction house scramble for a coveted masterpiece, are nonetheless a complex dance requiring careful steps. Legal legalese, ethical tightropes, and practical pirouettes all come into play. These partings, though influenced by ever-evolving artistic trends (think of them as the artistic equivalent of the latest dance craze), necessitate a firm grasp of contractual obligations, a commitment to ethical conduct, and a strategic plan for the future (think choreography for a successful artistic exit).

By striking a harmonious balance between calculated business decisions and unwavering integrity and professionalism, artists and galleries can navigate these separations with the grace of a farewell waltz. Transparency, respect, and trust – these are the essential ingredients for a smooth artistic "détente".

Ultimately, such graceful goodbyes foster a thriving and dynamic art community, ensuring the artistic melody continues to play, even as partners change. So, the next time you find yourself contemplating an artistic separation, remember: a focus on these elements can ensure a parting that's less of a chaotic scramble and more of a graceful farewell, allowing everyone to waltz off into their next artistic adventure.

---

¹https://www.artnews.com/art-news/news/bored-ape-yacht-club-nfts-stolen-2022-13-5-million-1234637674/

²Deloitte's 2023 Art & Culture Report: https://www.deloitte.com/ lu/en/services/financial-advisory/research/art-finance-report.html

³https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/30/arts/design/christies-hack-client-data.html

---

Gunna Freivalde is the legal maestro behind AMG Attorneys, where art and law collide in the most harmonious of ways. Based in Belgium, Spain, and Switzerland, Gunna is a legal ninja, wielding her expertise across borders with finesse.

And there's more! You'll also find her donning her arbitrator hat at The Court of Arbitration for Arts in The Hague, Netherlands - because who says legal proceedings can't be a work of art?

When she's not busy untangling legal knots or advocating for artistic justice (those rare moments), you can catch her donning her superhero cape as Legal Trustee at Tigers4Ever, a UK-based charity dedicated to wildlife conservation. Saving tigers by day, slaying legal dragons by night or vice versa - it's all in a day's work!

However, Gunna's most important role is being a full-time mom to two artistic teenagers and a furry squad of three cats, a dog, a horse, and a ferret (because every legal eagle needs a fuzzy sidekick).

And when the chaos of the day finally settles, you'll find Gunna unwinding with a well-deserved glass of wine, dreaming of a world where art reigns supreme, and justice is served with a side of creativity. Because hey, who says you can't change the world one masterpiece at a time?

AMG ATTORNEYS

Website

Instagram

LinkedIn

Art Law Group on Facebook